Home  »  Buy Cheese  »  Condiments


View Our Policies

  • Cheese Pairings

    Cheese Pairings


    New !!!New !  New! New!

    These  delightful compotes are created to pair with cheese! 2.3oz

    Give a little “kiss” to each cheese.

    “Black Figs” with macadamia nuts and pepper is perfect with Blue Yonder and Cayuga Blue.

    “Golden Apples” with tender pistachios and cinnamon is delicious with Finger Lakes Gold, Lake Effect Cheddar and Shire.

    “Peaches and Apricots” with goji berries and cardamom is excellent with Sheldrake Moon.

    “Raspberries” with rose petals and Sichuan pepper is brilliant with Chevre and Feta.

  • Crispy French Cracker - Sea Salt

    Crispy French Cracker – Sea Salt

    Toasty french Waffle crackers made by Tresors. Perfect with cheese.

  • Crispy French Crackers - Rosemary

    Crispy French Crackers – Rosemary

    Toasty french waffle crackers made by Tresors. Perfect with cheese!

  • Honey Rock Farm Honeys

    Honey Rock Farm Honeys

    Honey Rock Farm is based out of the Finger Lakes and produces a wide variety of different honeys.

    There are only 1 item left in stock.
  • Honey Yum

    Honey Yum

    Local Cinnamon Creamed Honey from HoneyRock Farms.

    Ingredients: Honey & Cinnamon

    There are only 1 item left in stock.
  • Knapp Farm Jams

    Knapp Farm Jams

    A selection of excellent locally made jams, chutney & butters.

    Try these pairings:

    Brambleberry with Sheldrake Moon or Finger Lakes Gold

    Raspberry Hot Pepper with Chevre or Blue Yonder

    Strawberry Rhubarb with Lake Effect Cheddar or Shire

  • Marcona Almonds

    Marcona Almonds

    These notoriously buttery almonds are native to and imported from Spain.

    Perfect on a cheese board!

  • Membrillo


    A thick sliceable fruit jelly made from quince that is native to and imported from Spain. Reminiscent of apple and pear it is very nice with any cheese and especially the Finger Lakes Gold!

  • Membrillo Combo

    Membrillo Combo

    This Combo includes 8oz of  Chevre, 4oz of Finger Lakes Gold Reserve and a box of yummy Membrillo.

    $22. You save $2.50

  • Mojo's Sauce 5 FL oz

    Mojo’s Sauce 5 FL oz

    New!  New!    New!

    Did you know that hot sauces and cheese can play nice together?

    Mojo’s Sauces are produced in Ithaca from local vegetables and a variety

    of Chili peppers. These sauces are full of flavor!

    We offer 3  varieties:

    Sunshine Carrot is a carrot juice based sauce enhanced to medium heat

    with Scotch Bonnet , Hungarian and Serrano peppers.

    Lemongrass juice and ginger  round out the flavor.  5 FL OZ

    Beet’s Me! is a beet  juice based sauce enhanced to medium heat

    with Green Cayenne , Hungarian,  Jalapeno and Serrano Peppers.

    Parsley, ginger juice and spices make this sauce special.

    Smokin’ Hot Heirloom gets its hot heat from smoked Habaneros

    and smoked heirloom tomatoes as well as pickled hot peppers.

  • Sweet Bliss Bundle Save $6.00

    Sweet Bliss Bundle Save $6.00

    What’s in it?

    •  16 oz local Cinnamon infused creamed honey . Put some on your Cayuga Blue and be transported to Bliss Bayou  -$15 value
    • 6oz local Raspberry Hot Pepper Jam. Add it to your Sheldrake Moon and go “Wow”_ -$7.20 value
    • 8oz Sheldrake Moon, it’s a delight on its own-$11 value
    • 4oz Cayuga Blue, earthy goodness-$7 value
    • 8oz Battistone Soppressata with wine and peppercorns. Yum!-$9.50 value
    • Tresors Wafer Crackers. Nice little crunch!-$4.60 value
  • Taralli Italian Crackers

    Taralli Italian Crackers

    These crackers are  imported from Italy. They are soda crackers with a bit more “meat” to them and are lovely when dipped into fondue!